The Letter of Last Resort: A Debate on Second Strike Nuclear Ethics

BBC hosted the following discussion:

What would you tell the commander of the Trident submarine at sea to do if the UK was destroyed, and its leadership killed, by a surprise nuclear strike?

To retaliate? Or not?

That is the question for Paddy O'Connell's guests: David Rodin (Oxford; Carnegie Council Global Ethics Fellow), Commodore Tim Hare, and Caroline Lucas (MP) debate what orders they would give in a "Letter of Last Resort."

The letters contain orders from beyond the grave. They are written out by every new Prime Minister, within days of entering office, four times -- one for each of Britain's four Trident submarines.

When a PM leaves office his or her orders are removed from the submarines, destroyed unread and replaced by the orders of their successor.

You can only give one order in the Letter of Last Resort. What should it be?

Listen to the full discussion on BBC Radio and add your thoughts here.

------------

PHOTO CREDIT: Defence Images (CC).

Tags: GEF, deterrence, ethics, military, navy, nuclear, peace, war

Views: 389

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

The MAD (MutuallyAssuredDestruction) Policy between US and Soviets has Worked, to date. For such policy to be effective it needs to be Declared Beforehand that a Nuclear Attack would automatically  trigger a nuclear response. That Order would be in a "Letter of Last Resort" ;  the Trident Submarine Commander would need to have received the  Launch Enable Signal from the Launch Authority. (In the case of the US from POTUS (launch suitcase).

Another policy might be:" No 1st Use - Guranteed 2nd Use" ! (See "The Second Nuclear Age", Paul Bracken.)

RSS

Carnegie Council

The New Rules of War: Victory in the Age of Durable Disorder, with Sean McFate

"Nobody fights conventionally except for us anymore, yet we're sinking a big bulk, perhaps the majority of our defense dollars, into preparing for another conventional war, which is the very definition of insanity," declares national security strategist and former paratrooper Sean McFate. The U.S. needs to recognize that we're living in an age of "durable disorder"--a time of persistent, smoldering conflicts--and the old rules no longer apply.

The Crack-Up: 1919 & the Birth of Modern Korea, with Kyung Moon Hwang

Could the shared historical memory of March 1 ever be a source of unity between North Koreans and South Koreans? In this fascinating episode of The Crack-Up series that explores how 1919 shaped the modern world, Professor Kyung Moon Hwang discusses the complex birth of Korean nationhood and explains how both North and South Korea owe their origins and their national history narratives to the events swirling around March 1, 1919.

The Sicilian Expedition and the Dilemma of Interventionism

The Peloponnesian War has lessons for U.S. foreign policy beyond the Thucydides Trap. Johanna Hanink reminds us that the debate over moral exceptionalism and interventionism is nothing new.

SUBSCRIBE TODAY

VIDEOS

SUPPORT US

GEO-GOVERNANCE MATTERS

© 2019   Created by Carnegie Council.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service


The views and opinions expressed in the media, comments, or publications on this website are those of the speakers or authors and do not necessarily reflect or represent the views and opinions held by Carnegie Council.