Comparing Cost- Fossil Fuels v.s. Renewable Energy

Austin Schiano

UN Sustainability Professional

Carnegie Council New Leaders Member

It is clear as with any major innovation, that the global economies shift toward renewable energy will not be due to a moral imperative but rather an economic incentive. Now, despite the disdain many of us will hold at this claim, we can take comfort in the fact that renewables are becoming increasingly efficient and cost effective.

A recent IMF Working Paper entitled “How Large are Global Energy Subsidies” puts this issue into perspective. David Coady, division chief at the Fiscal Affairs Department of the IMF and one of the report’s authors states that the text ” compares the cost that people pay for fossil fuel-based energy to the cost that they would pay if they calculated the true cost of the damage done by their consumption”. The report in short finds that “the potential fiscal, environmental, and welfare impacts of energy subsidy reform are substantial”. Now, what’s important to understand is that the report expand the understanding of “subsidy” (direct financial governmental support or specific policies) to include “externalities” (ex: damage to public health and the environment, and the amount of mone...). When both subsidies and externalities are analyzed, it is concluded that fossil fuels cost the global economy a projected 5.3 Trillion in 2015. This is money that governments and consumers alike are losing.

Late in August 2015 prior to the COP 21 summit, Bloomberg news reported that:

“The median cost of producing so-called baseload power that is available all the time from natural gas, coal and atomic plants was about $100 a megawatt-hour for 2015 compared with about $200 for solar, which dropped from $500 in 2010. Those costs take into account investment, fuel, maintenance and dismantling of the installations over their lifetimes and vary widely between countries and plants.”

The International Energy Agency report which the article is based upon makes note that the cost for energy production by varying means is not perfectly stable. However, As the Bloomberg article states: “Coal plants will become as much as 70 percent more expensive if they include equipment to capture carbon emissions while offshore wind and solar costs are expected to fall. New utility-size solar installations could produce power for less than $100 a megawatt-hour before 2025 in the sunniest regions while panels on rooftops could reach that in five years after”.

What makes all this all the more intriguing is that countries like PortugalDenmark, and Morocco have all seen large-scale implementation of renewable energy programs with fantastic success. It will now be our duty to promote them.


Views: 2815


You need to be a member of Global Ethics Network to add comments!

Join Global Ethics Network

Carnegie Council

Tackling Inequality in the United States, with "Born on Third Base" Chuck Collins

Chuck Collins grew up in a wealthy family and gave away his fortune at the age of 26, yet he realizes that he still has advantages accrued over generations. The current level of inequality is bad for society as a whole, he declares. "It is not in anyone's interest to keep moving toward a sort of economic and racial apartheid." But it doesn't have to be this way. It can be reversed.

Top Risks and Ethical Decisions 2018 with Eurasia Group's Ian Bremmer

Probably the most dangerous geopolitical environment in decades-China, AI, Trump, end of Pax Americana--yes, it's very bad. But all these challenges energize political scientist Ian Bremmer to do his best work! Don't miss this great talk.

Global Ethics Forum Preview: False Dawn: Protest, Democracy, and Violence in the New Middle East, with Steven A. Cook

Next time on Global Ethics Forum, Council on Foreign Relations Senior Fellow Steven Cook discusses the violent aftermath of the Arab Spring. In this excerpt, Cook describes how and why Washington got its response wrong to revolutions in the Middle East and North Africa, with a special focus on Libya.



© 2018   Created by Carnegie Council.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service